• D. David - Watertown

    When I moved to Watertown a few years ago I contacted McEvoy Ltd, to get prices on insurance. Within the first 60 days of getting my new policy I was involved in a motor home accident on Christmas Eve. I contacted my agent at home and after calming me down and asking if I was okay, they processed to claim in a very professional manner.

  • J. Ashcroft - Carthage

    In January of 1996 I met with David Buskey of McEvoy Ltd. to discuss my Homeowners and Auto Insurance coverage whom I had with Nationwide. McEvoy Insurance was able to place me with a top rated carrier and saved us approximately 15% off my previous coverage. The following year I was involved in an accident in which significant damage was done to my car. The claim service I received was fantastic.

    In the winter of 1997 I had wind damage to the roof of my house. I was pleasantly surprised when my agent was able to deliver a check to repair the damage the day after I filed the claim.

  • P. More - Mannsville

    Last year I had my Auto Insurance with GEICO. I contacted McEvoy Insurance and they were able to save me over $160 a year.

  • B. Augustus - Watertown

    McEvoy Insurance has provided my family with our insurance needs since 2007. My decision to place our coverage with their company was based on a high level of service with a local company at an affordable price. Claims are processed in an expedient and professional manner. Any questions pertaining to coverage are fully explained, and coverage needs are reviewed on a regular basis. I highly recommend McEvoy for personal service from a locally owned and operated business.

  • D. Lelakowski - Carthage

    I have been a customer for almost 20 years and I still recommend people to take their insurance needs to McEvoy Insurance. I always feel they put my best interest first, every year taking the time to reevaluate my insurance needs for my small business to my personal.

    -Dawn Lelakowski, Owner of Church Street Diner

Personal Insurance

Personal Property Insurance Icon

Insurance for all your personal needs including auto insurance, homeowners insurance and other coverages such as renters, boat, theft, and more.

Commercial Insurance


We can help you build and protect your business by providing customized insurance solutions to support you and your budget.

Get A Quote


Find the best insurance available to suit your needs - get started today with a FREE quote.




McEvoy Insurance

McEvoy Insurance
1613 State St 
Watertown, NY 13601



Business Hours
Monday-Friday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
After hours by appointment.

Member of the Greater Watertown Area Chamber of Commerce

Est. 1930

We Accept: